MostMagic: The Gatheringgames can be interpreted as a sort of race.

There’s no respite for your opponents as you inflict the deck’s titular endless punishment.

Endless Punishment Commander Deck List

Here’s thefull deck listfor the Endless Punishment Commander deck.

Image of The Lord of Pain alongside several other cards from the Endless Punishment Commander deck.

What sets the good red/black decks apart from the bad isharnessing that damage for something greater.

Endless Punishment does that best through its boxtopper commander, Valgavoth, Harrow of Souls.

Valgavoth even comes with built-in evasion and protection thanks to the flying and ward keywords.

Image of Tyvar beating up some zombies on Duskmourn in Magic The Gathering.

Barbflare Gremlin art by Matt Stewart

Tap into some of the best cards for fright night.

Then with Valgavoth at the fore, you attack with your giant moth Demon to win.

There’sno shortage of damage dealers in Endless Punishment.

Image of Barbflare Gremlin card art by Matt Stewart

Barbflare Gremlin art by Matt Stewart

Red/black decks often become the center of attention during games of multiplayer Commander.

To help keep yourself alive, Endless Punishmentfocuses on creatures for solid defense(32 besides Valgavoth himself).

However, you’re likely to need more given how red/black has trouble making friends.

MTG The Mindskinner card art with the card next to it.

Endless Punishment could also do with a little refinement.

We’ll be looking to cut those cards in favor of more synergistic options in the next section.

While they’re all decent cards, they could be replaced by something that plays better with Valgavoth.

Image of the Magic The Gathering Card Valgavoth Harrower of Souls by Chris Cold.

Finally,Theater of Horrorsis an expensive way to deal damage thatcould be improved with a minor substitution.

For when it would take a miracle to win your next game.

We’re going to provide both in our budget substitutions.

Split image showing a gremlin, art of the Unsettling Twins MTG card, and Jigsaw from saw.

Great value for a fun red trick.

Karazikar, the Eye Tyrant

Karazikar, the Eye Tyrant is perfect for Valgavoth.

Plus you get a 5/5 and a source of card draw out of the deal.

Image The Lord of Pain card art by Greg Staples.

The Lord of Pain art by Greg Staples

It’s also a cheap Lizard with four toughness, making it great on defense.

Nobody can stare at free Treasure and not use it for long.

And once those Treasures start cracking, Valgavoth is laughing.

Aminatou holds her staff in front of some key cards in the Miracle Worker deck.

Reckless Impulse

Reckless Impulse is better than Grab the Prize.

Rug of Smothering

Everyone casts spells, which means Rug of Smothering offers consistent damage on opposing turns.

It also damages you, but as they say: no pain, no gain!

Image of Karazikar, the Eye Tyrant art by Jason A. Engle

Karazikar, the Eye Tyrant art by Jason A Engle

Underworld Dreams ensures that opponents suffer for it, and Valgavoth grows in power.

Untimely Malfunction

Utility hate, redirection, and combat tricks all in a single two-mana spell.

It’s hard to beat Untimely Malfunction’s utility.

Image of Bolt Bend card.

An easy way to double-check they die is to block with them, which also helpfully triggers Valgavoth.

Other Budget Upgrades To Consider

Blink and you’ll miss it.

Image of Chandra, Awakened Inferno card.

Image of Karazikar, the Eye Tyrant card.

Image of Magebane Lizard card.

Image of Pain Distributor card.

Image of Reckless Impulse card.

Image of Roiling Vortex card.

Image of Rug of Smothering card.

Image of Underworld Dreams card.

Image of Untimely Malfunction card.

Image of Zulaport Cutthroat card.

Image of Zurzoth, Chaos Rider card.

MTG Niko, Light of Hope card artwork with the card next to it.

Tabletop

Magic: The Gathering